Cheddar Cheeses
Aged New York Sharp and Protester Cheddar Cheese
Aged to perfection between 6 months and 10 years, these New York State Cheddars are beyond delicious. We offer these fantastic cheeses in random weight bars, and 5lb or 10lb blocks. Please select from the available selections below for cheddars up to 5 years of age. Please call or email for current pricing and availability of cheddars aged from 6 to 10 years.
NY XXX Sharp Cheddar 1lb Bar
This 3 Year Old NY Cheddar is fantastic. Just the right amount of sharpness to accent any recipe. Or perfect on crackers. Random Weight Bars fluctuate between .95 and 1.05 lb.
$8.99 EA
NY XXX Sharp Cheddar 5lb Block
This 3 Year Old NY Cheddar is fantastic. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 4.9 and 5.1 lb.
$42.45 EA
NY XXX Sharp Cheddar 10lb Block
This 3 Year Old NY Cheddar is fantastic. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 9.90 and 10.10 lb.
$79.90 EA
NY XXXX Sharp Cheddar 1lb Bar
You'll love this 4 Year Old NY Sharp Cheddar. Random Weight Bars fluctuate between .90 and 1.10 lb.
$9.99 EA
NY XXXX Sharp Cheddar 5lb Block
You'll love this 4 Year Old NY Sharp Cheddar. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 4.9 and 5.10 lb.
$47.45 EA
NY XXXX Sharp Cheddar 10lb Block
You'll love this 4 Year Old NY Sharp Cheddar. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 9.50 and 11.25 lb.
$89.90 EA
NY XXXXX Sharp Cheddar 1lb Bar
This Fantastic 5 Year Old NY Sharp Cheddar is hard to beat. Random Weight Bars fluctuate between .95 and 1.10 lb.
$10.99 EA
NY XXXXX Sharp Cheddar 5lb Block
This Fantastic 5 Year Old NY Sharp Cheddar is hard to beat. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 4.90 and 5.10 lb.
$52.45 EA
NY XXXXX Sharp Cheddar 10lb Block
This Fantastic 5 Year Old NY Sharp Cheddar is hard to beat. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 9.90 and 10.10 lb.
$99.90 EA
NY Adams Reserve X Sharp Bar
This award winning NY X-Sharp Cheddar has fantastic flavor, sharpness, and texture. Aged for over 12 months and a great addition to any meal or snack. Net Wt. 16oz.
$7.99 EA
NY Mild Cheddar Bar
Better Mild Cheddar Cheese cannot be found. Perfect for many recipes. Random Weight range from .9lb to 1.10lb.
$5.99 lb
NY Sharp Cheddar Bar
Fantastic 6 - 9 Month aged NY Sharp Cheddar Bars. Random Weight Bars fluctuate between .95 and 1.10 lb.
$6.99 EA
NY Sharp Cheddar 5lb Block
Random Weight NY Sharp Cheddar Blocks. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 4.9 and 5.1 lb.
$32.45 EA
NY Sharp Cheddar 10lb Block
Random Weight NY Sharp Cheddar Blocks. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 9.90 and 10.10 lb.
$59.90 EA
NY Sharp Half Wheel w/ Wax
New York Sharp Cheddar aged in Black Wax. Waxed Half Wheels are approximately 1.50 lb.
$16.25 EA
NY Sharp Qtr Wedge w/ Wax
New York Sharp Cheddar aged in Black Wax. Waxed Wedges are approximately .75lb
$8.25 EA
NY X-Sharp Cheddar Bar
Random Weight NY X-Sharp Cheddar Bars. Random Weight Bars fluctuate between .95 and 1.10 lb.
$6.99 lb
NY X-Sharp Cheddar Block 5lb
Random Weight NY X-Sharp Cheddar Blocks. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 4.90 and 5.10 lb.
$32.45 EA
NY X-Sharp Cheddar Block 10lb
Random Weight NY X-Sharp Cheddar Blocks. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 9.90 and 10.10 lb.
$59.90 EA
Protester Cheddar 1-lb Block
This 2 Year Old NY Cheddar is fantastic. $1.00 of every pound sold to go towards the purchase of our new location. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between .95 and 1.05 lb.
$7.99 EA
Protester Cheddar 2-lb Block
This 2 Year Old NY Cheddar is fantastic. $1.00 of every pound sold to go towards the purchase of our new location. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 1.95 and 2.05 lb.
$15.49 EA
Protester Cheddar 5-lb Block
This 2 Year Old NY Cheddar is fantastic. $1.00 of every pound sold to go towards the purchase of our new location. Random Weight Blocks fluctuate between 4.95 and 5.05 lb.
$37.99 EA